Enshrined in both the Constitution and state and federal law is a criminal defendant’s right to due process, which includes the right to a fair trial. The HCAO is the largest prosecuting office in Minnesota, handling over 10,000 cases every calendar year, and the office’s compliance with due process and the requirements of the prosecuting authority associated with it are of paramount importance to both the office and the community the office serves.
As a prosecuting office, the HCAO has a statutory and constitutional obligation to turn over to a defendant in a criminal case information within the prosecutor’s possession and control that is exculpatory to a defendant’s guilt or that impacts the credibility of any State witnesses. This obligation is colloquially called the State’s “Brady/Giglio” obligation, named after the two United States Supreme Court cases where this obligation originated.
Brady/Giglio information can include information contained in disciplinary records for police officers, statements from witnesses in a case to members of the prosecution team, and records from collateral criminal or civil court matters. A defendant has a right to know prior to trial, for example, if the officer who wrote the search warrant that led to the discovery of pivotal evidence against them has any history of being disciplined for lying. Some other examples of conduct by officers or other State witnesses involved in the case that would warrant disclosure under the State’s Brady/Giglio obligation include evidence of the witness having used excessive force in the past, of the witness having a demonstrable bias against a person or group of people, or of the witness failing to properly handle evidence.
In 2023, the HCAO created the Brady Team, whose full-time work centers around the office’s compliance with Brady/Giglio. The Brady Team works tirelessly to ensure that the HCAO is complying with its Brady/Giglio obligations, and their work exists in the complicated intersection of the prosecutor’s obligations under the Constitution and the rules of criminal procedure and the Minnesota Government Data Practices Act, which controls how government data is identified, controlled, and disseminated. The Brady Team ensures the HCAO’s compliance with Brady/Giglio by reviewing the disciplinary records for any law enforcement witnesses of the State and making any appropriate disclosures from those records to defense, by drafting court orders to have any private or confidential records that could contain Brady/Giglio information securely disclosed to the appropriate authority for review, and by tracking for disclosure any judicial orders where a judge opines on the credibility of police officers or other State witnesses, among many other tasks. The Brady Team also works directly with the over 35 different law enforcement agencies with state and local legislators to develop policies and procedures that adequately safeguard the privacy rights of individuals implicated in potential Brady/Giglio data while ensuring that all defendants prosecuted in Hennepin County are afforded due process as required by law.
The Brady/Giglio Unit also processes requests from law enforcement agencies conducting background checks for prospective officers. If you are a law enforcement agency seeking such information, please email CA.DisclosureInfo@hennepin.us.